Share this website!


E-Mail this story to a friend

Volume 12 Number 4
Spring/Summer 2014

'WHY BE GOOD?' RESTORATION COMPLETE!
FIRST SCREENINGS IN 85 YEARS BEGIN

Why Be Good? Ad 1 Why Be Good? Ad 2 Why Be Good? Ad 3 Why Be Good? Still Why Be Good? Music Information
Colleen Moore's last silent film, WHY BE GOOD? has been restored by Warner Bros' Ned Price using The Vitaphone Project's Ron Hutchinson's music and sound effects soundtrack disks. The film's first screening in 85 years took place on July 4, 2014 at the Cineteca Bologna festival in Italy. As this issue was going to press, details for additional screenings in Los Angeles and New York City were being firmed up.

Beginning with DON JUAN, Warner Brothers announced that all of their features would be released with a synchronized music and sound effects Vitaphone soundtrack. Theatres not equipped for Vitaphone would show these films with their own orchestral accompaniments.

Warner Brothers was riding high with the success of Vitaphone, and in September 1928 bought First National Pictures along with all of the star contracts that studio owned. Colleen Moore was First National's top star, and so her pictures got the full Vitaphone treatment.

Once WHY BE GOOD? was completed, a print of the film was sent to the Victor Talking Machine Company in Camden, NJ. There, an original musical accompaniment drawn largely from popular tunes of the day was created to match each scene. Judicious sound effects (like door knocks, horns honking, etc.) were also added.

As the musicians watched the film, they played from the original score that was recorded on a 16 inch wax master. Noteworthy for the Colleen Moore feature disks is that the musical performances are jazzy, toe-tapping and highly reflective of the late 1920's. Jazz historians have identified such legendary musicians as Jimmy Dorsey, Phil Napoleon, Joe Venuti and Eddie Lang on the disks.

Until the late 1990s both SYNTHETIC SIN (her next to last silent) and WHY BE GOOD? were thought to be lost. There is an extremely high mortality rate for films released during the 1927-29 transition period. A large fire at Warner Brothers in the 1950's destroyed the then-known prints.

Fast forward to 2002 and New York's Film Forum. Prior to a screening, Ron updated the audience on latest activities of The Vitaphone Project. He casually mentioned that he recently acquired all the soundtrack disks for Colleen Moore's WHY BE GOOD? , and said something to the effect that "unfortunately, this is a lost film."

Film historian Joe Yranski, who ran the film library at the Donnell Media Center, was a friend of Colleen Moore and knew more about this film than probably anybody on the planet, yelled out "No it's not! I know where it is!" The full house at Film Forum cheered.

Since then, the Project and Warner Bros have worked towards getting the lone 35mm nitrate print of WHY BE GOOD? along with Moore's previous scored silent SYNTHETIC SIN ('28), back to the US for restoration. Last year Ned Price succeeded in negotiating with Cineteca Italiana di Milano to do just that. Disks were transferred by sound engineer Seth Winner. And the print was finally synchronized and finished in early June.

Hear some of the soundtrack for WHY BE GOOD? here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_GyYapvkcw


LATE BREAKING NEWS!

Just as we were going to press, the restored WHY BE GOOD? was screened in Bologna, Italy at the Cineteca Bologna "Il Cinema Ritrovato" festival on July 4th. This was the first time the public saw and heard this film in 85 years. One friend of the Project was there, and kindly sent us this capsule review of the event:

"The room was packed with at least fifty people standing on the sides -- "the most anticipated movie of the whole festival" I heard someone nearby say. Ned Price of Warner Brothers gave a short intro that was most gracious -- stressing how this was a collaboration and specifically thanking you (Ron Hutchinson) by name and the Project.

The film started -- no sound! So it restarted again, and wow what a difference. First of all, it looks amazing (no exaggeration) -- absolutely pristine. And the soundtrack was synched to physical actions (honking cars, blaring trumpets, etc.) so it felt almost like a score plus actual effects -- what a huge difference it made. The movie itself is a total Jazz Age romp -- fantastic scenes of Deco penthouse parties, Charleston dancing contests, with funny slangy intertitles. The audience loved it. And I heard someone else say, "That was the best movie I saw all week!"

You (personally) and the Vitaphone Project are also thanked in a title card.

Congratulations -- this one's a real crowd pleaser and the discs really add to it."


LOST TECHNICOLOR 35mm NITRATE FOUND IN ENGLAND!

Spools of found nitrate film On With The Show Pic 1 On With The Show Pic 2
Malcolm Billingsley, The Vitaphone Project's British emissary, made an absolutely incredible and important discovery this spring. Twenty-five spools of 35 mm Technicolor nitrate film, running 20 seconds to a little over one minute each, were found at a small British museum. The film's condition is outstanding, Malcolm has identified that the clips include previously lost sequences from ON WITH THE SHOW! (WB/'29), SALLY (WB/'30), THE SHOW OF SHOWS (WB/'30) and part of an already discovered fragment from GOLD DIGGERS OF BROADWAY (WB/'29)., However, every spool and frame has not yet been inspected so there may be some surprises still in store. The source of these kind of short 35mm nitrate fragments seems to be from toy projectors that were marketed in the twenties and thirties. Short spools of unneeded theatrical film would be included with the projector kit. Considering nitrate's flammability, not the safest toy!

Arrangements have already been made for George Eastman House to receive the spools for restoration and ultimately synchronize with surviving Vitaphone disks. In the case of ON WITH THE SHOW, which was the first all Technicolor talkie feature, a black and white print survives. So the color fragment could be dropped into the appropriate reel. The same applies to SALLY, and SHOW OF SHOWS, which each had brief Technicolor sequences found and restored about 25 years ago. Unrelated to this most recent discovery are 60-90 second Technicolor fragments of previously lost GOLD DIGGERS OF BROADWAY and ON WITH THE SHOW footage found by Darren Nemeth. These will now most likely be folded into the George Eastman House project. That work will be overseen by GEH's Technicolor guru James Layton, who recently completed work on three early color talkie shorts restorations: PIRATES (MGM/'30), MANHATTAN SERENADE (MGM/'29) and THE SULTAN'S JESTER (Vitaphone/'29). James reports those restorations are now just completed and plans to screen them are in the works.


WARNER ARCHIVE ISSUES VITAPHONE COMEDY COLLECTION #2 DVD SET!

Click here to order now! Volume 2 is now available! Click on the image to the left to order your copy now!

Shemp Howard's rise as a solo comedian in four short years is charted in this series of twenty shorts, including his famed run as Knobby Walsh in the Joe Palooka series based on the hit comic strip. Titles on the DVD are listed below:

  • Dizzy and Daffy (1934)
  • Why Pay Rent? (1935)
  • Serves You Right (1935)
  • On the Wagon (1935)
  • The Officer's Mess (1935)
  • While the Cat's Away (1936)
  • Absorbing Junior (1936)
  • Joe Palooka: For the Love of Pete (1936)
  • Joe Palooka: Here's Howe (1936)
  • Joe Palooka: Punch and Beauty (1936)
  • Joe Palooka: The Choke's on You (1936)
  • Joe Palooka: The Blonde Bomber (1936)
  • Joe Palooka: Kick Me Again (1937)
  • Joe Palooka:Taking the Count (1937)

  • 90 YEARS LATER, VITA STAMPERS FOUND AT WB

    Vitaphone soundtrack disks are rare. But the metal stampers used by Victor Talking Machine Company to press them are far more rare. These approximately 18 inch diameter metal masters were used to press the several hundred copies of shellac Vitaphone disks that were then shipped to theatres with accompanying (otherwise mute) film.

    Readers of VITAPHONE NEWS will recall an earlier issue in which we reported that in 1941, thousands of stampers were melted down for their scrap value. That is why their survival rate is so low.

    Meltdown Order
    1941 Scrap report for melted-down stampers

    So when the Project recently heard from Warner Bros sound engineer Edward Stephens that he had found 26 mainly 1926-29 Vitaphone soundtrack metal stampers, we were amazed. These were apparently always there on the old First National --- now WB --- lot since the earliest days of Viatphone. We've listed what was found in our "Disc-overies" report in this issue. The earliest stamper is for Vitaphone #189 for THOMAS M. WATSON SPEECH. Recorded on June 4, 1926, it's one of the earliest Vitaphones recorded at the studio, and has Alexander Graham Bell's assistant describing the invention of the telephone.

    Several of the stampers represent the only known surviving sound element portion for previously mute shorts. We've noted which films are now restorable as a result of this find. The stampers can be played back directly using a "U" shaped styli which rides the portion of the surface that stamped the grooves into the shellac.


    DISC-OVERIES

    Ron Hutchinson finds Vitaphone records!
    As mentioned in this issue, a large group of original metal Vitaphone disk stampers were discovered at Warner Brothers recently. Here is the rundown of what was found. An asterisk means the found recording now makes a restoration with the surviving picture elements possible:
    And from another collection held by the son of a 1928-73 theatre projectionist: And in a Georgia archive


    ANOTHER ELMER RAGUSE PHOTO FROM THE HAL ROACH STUDIOS

    Stan Laurel, Elmer Raguse, Oliver Hardy with microphone equipment
    Elmer Raguse was the Academy Award nominated sound engineer at the Hal Roach Studios.
    Thanks to Craig Raguse for the use of this photo!


    VITAPHONE T-SHIRTS & STICKERS NOW HERE!

    Vitaphone sticker
    Clear vinyl Vitaphone stickers are available NOW! Perfect for your car windows, black guitar cases, your mirrors, just tons of places you can put these! The sticker is clear except for the Vitaphone logo which is white and meant for the outside of the window, so all you see is the Vitaphone logo. These stickers are durable, waterproof, and made for all seasons! Cost is $3.00 per sticker. Shipping is $.75 in the USA (no matter how many you purchase) and $1.50 for all regions outside the USA (no matter how many you purchase). Payments will be handled securely though PayPal (the email address to send the payment to is louie9@charter.net) where you can use your account. Credit card payments can also be accepted through this method.
    Stickers

    He can also accept money orders and personal checks. Please email him (louie9@charter.net) for his address & when using personal checks, Ships after check has cleared the bank. Orders will ship as soon as they are received.

    Vitaphone T-Shirt
    And they're here! A new batch of beautiful Vitaphone T-shirts are now available. Checkout our website to see them in color. Here's how to order from Tim Reed: KJ5KX@yahoo.com

    2-color silkscreen logo on Royal Blue tee. Port and Company 100% cotton shirt. Sizes: S M L XL $14 + USPS Priority shipping.

    Shipping cost: 1-3 shirts:$6, 4-6 shirts:$12, 2XL add $2, 3XL add $3, 4XL add $4, 5XL add $5, 6XL add $6. Larger orders, $6 for every three shirts.

    Sizing (L x H): S: 27"x18" M: 29"x20" L: 30"x22" XL: 31"x24" 2XL: 33"x26" 3XL: 34"x28" 4XL: 35"x30" 5XL: 36"x32" 6XL: 37"x34"

    If your order isn't in the drop down below, Please order from Tim Reed via PayPal to KJ5KX@yahoo.com and specify "Vitaphone Shirt". These are not stock items, so Tim must take orders for a short time and then have the shirts manufactured. Delivery times will be affected accordingly.

    T-Shirts


    VITAPHONE PROJECT BY THE NUMBERS

    Here are a few numbers we're often asked about….
    • NUMBER OF SHORTS RESTORED TO DATE: ~95
    • NUMBER OF SHORTS IN RESTORATION PIPELINE: 53
    • VITAPHONE SHORTS SURVINING W/PICTURE, NO SOUND: ~325
    • VITAPHONE SHORTS SURVIVING W/SOUND, NO PICTURE: ~80
    • VITAPHONE SHORTS NOT SURVIVING AT ALL: ~125
    • COST TO RESTORE 1 REEL SHORT THRU UCLA: $8,000
    • VITAPHONE SHORTS CURRENTLY ON WARNER ARCHIVE DVD's: ~ 250


    LOST JAZZ SHORT FOUND, RESTORATION ALREADY FUNDED
    Me and the Boys Review
    Film jazz historian Mark Cantor located a long lost 1929 Ben Pollack orchestra short filmed in the US but made only for British consumption. The lone 35mm print was found in Australia and the Project has already arranged the needed funding for its restoration. A major jazz discovery!


    PEOPLE


    WATCH VITAPHONE SHORTS ON YOUTUBE.COM!

    Watch The Operation now! Watch Corn on the Cop now! Watch The Night Court now! Watch The Happy Hottentots now! Watch Lamb Chops now!
    While the quality isn't as good as those found on the DVD's, there are plenty of shorts to be found online. For the best quality available, buy one of the DVD sets and help support film preservation!


    THANK-YOU GIFTS FOR DONORS!!

    Your generous donations help to keep our Project going. Escalating printing and mailing costs make your support even more important than ever. While not tax-deductible, your donation allows us to continue spreading the word and seeking out disks and film elements for future restorations. Large donations for actual restorations go directly to UCLA Film and Television Archive (where support is tax deductible).

    NEW!     NEW!    NEW!    NEW!    NEW!   NEW!

    NEW with this issue - we now are offering TEN new CDs of peppy, hot dance and personality 78s from the early talkie era. If you ordered our "hot and peppy 78s" CD last time there are still nine more new ones now available! You can email us at ron@vitaphoneproject.com for content. First CD for a $50 donation, $75 for two, $100 for 4 and get all ten CDs for a contribution of $200!

    A new BRITISH PATHETONE VIDEO DVD, featuring sound clip of bands and vaudeville. Includes Duke Ellington, Gracie Fields, Sophie Tucker, Casani Club Orchestra, Bert Lahr and Buddy Rogers, the Roy Fox, Jack Payne and Teddy Brown bands, and more. An hour of unseen material.
    A CD of hot and peppy 1928-32 78's that will keep your feet tapping. Great tunes from the early talkie era.

    Selections from the unique early studio recording disks reported in this issue. Includes actual on-set recordings with studio chatter before and after from early MGM shorts and features, Cliff Edwards, and unissued material from GOLDWYN FOLLIES

    A fantastic compilation of 1930-37 Warner Brothers opening titles music, many by musical director Ray Heindorf. Assembled by Peter Mintun.

    2012 VITAPHONE ACQUISITIONS - has the newly found audience entrance, exit and intermission music for HOLLYWOOD REVUE OF 1929, MAL HALLETT AND HIS ENTERTAINING ORCHESTRA (Vitaphone, 1929), Vitaphone #427 FRED WARING AND HIS PENNSYLVANIANS (1927) and the Overture disk for WARMING UP (Par/1928) (with Billy Murray).

    If you've sent in a donation lately, thanks! If you are receiving Vitaphone News and have not made contribution lately --- or ever -- please consider doing so now. In addition to thank-you audio CDs listed below, we are adding a few new items:

    Selected from the 70+ Vitaphone disks acquired earlier last year are two new CDs:

    2011 DISK-OVERIES VOL. 1 -includes soundtracks for 1929 shorts by Molly Picon and Dave Apollon, Ruth Etting with Arden & Ohman, Phil Baker and more.

    2011 DISK-OVERIES VOL. 2 includes tracks from REDSKIN, a Vitaphone 1929 theatre holiday promo, Charles King in the lost 1929 MGM Colortone CLIMBING THE GOLDEN STAIRS and Al Trahan, plus more.

    The above 2 CDs are individually for a $50 contribution, both for $75.

    For a $50 donation receive our DVD of twenty band, singing and vaudeville excerpts from 1930-39 British Pathetone shorts. Includes the bands of Billy Cotton, Harry Roy and Jack Hylton (recording at HMV in 1932!), plus Sophie Tucker, two clips with Al Bowlly, and many fun music hall and vaude acts. Just request our PATHETONE DVD when contributing!

    For donations of $50, you can choose from one of the listed CDs, or you can receive a great Shaw and Lee caricature T-shirt.

    And the following audio CDs are still available as thank-you gifts. These are unique, non-professional (but highly listenable) recordings of rare early talkie material. No fancy notes or packaging, but we are sure you'll enjoy them. Just let us know your choice (number of CDs is in parentheses)

  • KRAZY KAT CARTOON '29-'30 SOUNDTRACK (total of 10 tracks) (1)
  • '29-'30 COLUMBIA VICTOR GEMS SOUNDTRACKS (Vol 1 & 2) (1 CD each)
  • "TALES FROM THE ATTIC" - VITAPHONE ON WDVR (11/09) with Vitaphone Project's Ron Hutchinson. Nearly 3 hours (2) Ron Hutchinson on the air!
  • VICTOR PICT-UR-MUSIC DISCS Vol 1 (1)
  • VICTOR PICT-UR-MUSIC DISCS Vol. 2 (1)
  • BABY ROSE MARIE, THE CHILD WONDER ('29) - all known 1929-38 78's by this popular child star, plus tracks from her 3 Vitaphone shorts, features and even her 1938 radio show. (1)
  • WHY BE GOOD? Soundtrack - the complete jazzy Vitaphone discs for this soon to be restored 1929 silent starring Colleen Moore. Believed to feature Jimmy Dorsey, Phil Napoleon and Eddie Lang among others. (1)
  • MY MAN ('28) - all available discs from the lost Fanny Brice feature, plus trailer disc and contemporary 78's of film tunes. (2)
  • GOLD DIGGERS OF BROADWAY ('29) Vitaphone discs - 99% of the sound from this still substantially lost early Vitaphone feature. (1)
  • VITAPHONE SOUNDTRACKS - Vol 1-4 Selections from soundtrack discs from vaudeville, band and feature films. (4)
  • WHEELER & WOOLSEY TUNES (2 CD's) - includes virtually every one of the songs from their 1929-37 features. For real fans! (2)
  • Click on the button below to donate to The Vitaphone Project securely with any major credit card through PayPal!

    If you wish to send a check (not tax deductible) please make it payable to RON HUTCHINSON (NOT The Vitaphone Project) and send it to:

    Ron Hutchinson
    5 Meade Court
    Piscataway, NJ 08854

    THANK YOU!!

    Friend us on facebook 'The Vitaphone Project'


    ITEMS FOUND ON E-BAY

    Olivia DeHavilland Hearts In Exile Sheet Music Don Juan Sheet Music Noah's Ark Advertisement State Street Sadie Advertisement Show of Shows Sheet Music Crooner Sheet Music Al Jolson Sheet Music

    Search for Vitaphone items to buy on E-Bay here!


    ON SALE NOW!

    Movies and books related to Vitaphone can be purchased through Amazon.com by clicking on the items here!


    Share this website!

    Tweet
    E-Mail this story to a friend


    IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO BE NOTIFIED WHEN NEW ISSUES ARE ADDED TO THIS WEB SITE:

    Add me to the Vitaphone Project E-Mail List!

    Friend us on FaceBook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/113444792025031/



    VITAPHONE NEWS ISSN 1066-5951
    Corresponding Secretary & Editor Ron Hutchinson 5 Meade Court
    Piscataway, NJ 08854
    (732) 463-8521
    FAX: (732) 463-8521
    medusashaircut@erols.com
    ron@vitaphoneproject.com
    Database: Patrick Picking patrick@picking.com
    Co-Founders: John Newton newtonjj2@aol.com
    Sherwin Dunner jazzgypsy@verizon.net
    Vince Giordano vincegiordano@optonline.net
    Vitaphone Project Web Page Designer Patrick Picking
    patrick@picking.com
    Vitaphone Project Web Page http://www.vitaphoneproject.com medusashaircut@erols.com
    ron@vitaphoneproject.com
    Jeff Cohen's "Vitaphone Varieties" Site http://vitaphone.blogspot.com
    Leonard Maltin's Site http://www.leonardmaltin.com
    Talkie King http://talkieking.blogspot.com
    Nitrateville http://www.nitrateville.com
    "The Vitaphone Project" Friend us on facebook https://www.facebook.com/groups/113444792025031/
    OVERSEAS PROJECT EMMISSARIES UK:
    AUSTRALIA/NEW ZEALAND:

    SCANDANAVIA:

    Malcolm Billingsley

    Paul Brennan

    Jonas Nordin

    Sound insulated camera booth, to keep the noise of the camera from being picked up by the microphones



    This web site is maintained by Patrick Picking:  patrick@picking.com
    Copyright 1996-2014